Original air date: 04/27/2011 Runtime: 21:21 min. Jane pushes Brad to say "I love you" to his dad (Damon Wayans Sr.) At the hospital, Francis misconstrues Brad’s “I love you” as something wrong with him and has a heart attack that turns out only to be a panic attack. Dave and Alex become obsessed with playing with nerf guns. Penny meets a cute Italian and realizes that she can only speak Italian and understand him when she's drunk.
Original air date: 05/04/2011 Runtime: 20:54 min. Dave (Zachary Knighton) decides to quit his job and open a restaurant, only to learn that his friends think he is making a big mistake. Meanwhile, as Jane (Eliza Coupe) and Max (Adam Pally) vie over which of them would survive a zombie apocalypse, Penny (Casey Wilson) struggles to fit in with her new hipster boyfriend (guest star John Bobek) and his friends.
Original air date: 05/04/2011 Runtime: 21:18 min. Alex has a mouse in her apartment and asks Dave to come over and get rid of it humanely. While there, Dave falls in love with their old place. He lets the mouse go so he can spend more time there. Penny takes a Krav Maga class. Jane joins the class, is way too intense, and kicks the crap out of Penny. Max accuses Brad of being a “gay-cist”.
Original air date: 05/11/2011 Runtime: 20:56 min. Dave (Zachary Knighton) and Alex (Elisha Cuthbert) contemplate removing the tattoos they each got after a night of drinking, until they discover how painful it will be. And while Jane (Eliza Coupe) tries to convince Max (Adam Pally) not to be so judgmental about a prospective date (guest star O-T Fagbenle), Brad (Damon Wayans, Jr.) tries to assuage his guilt after his complaints cost a waiter his job.
Original air date: 05/18/2011 Runtime: 21:05 min. As Alex (Elisha Cuthbert) and Dave (Zachary Knighton) struggle to move past their wedding day breakup with the support of their family and friends, Jane (Eliza Coupe) fears that her marriage to Brad (Damon Wayans, Jr.) is in danger of losing its spark. And as Dave reluctantly moves in with Max (Adam Pally), Penny grudgingly agrees to attend a cooking class with Alex.
Original air date: 05/18/2011 Runtime: 21:02 min. When their favorite band is coming to Chicago, Dave (Zachary Knighton) and Alex (Elisha Cuthbert) refuse to let their recent break up stand in the way of everyone seeing them together. While Penny (Casey Wilson) is excited about reuniting with Tommy (guest star Nick Thune), a Barefoot Pedaler fiddler with whom she had a one-night stand, a YouTube video of the wedding day debacle reopens Dave’s emotional wounds.
Original air date: 05/25/2011 Runtime: 21:23 min. When her “safety husband” Shershow (guest star T.J. Miller) is engaged to be married, Penny (Casey Wilson) looks to replace him with Max (Adam Pally). But as the gang prepares to attend Penny’s chronically irresponsible friend’s wedding, Jane and Brad (Eliza Coupe and Damon Wayans, Jr.) discover that because Max failed to get a minister’s license prior to their own wedding, they aren’t officially married.